Friday, June 8, 2012

Character Arcs

Klute presents a complicated character arc, from numb professionalism to feeling person, though one that could be compared to Jan Morrow's in Pillow Talk, who must also allure a reluctant male into a relationship/sex (only implied of course in the latter film).  Jan isn't suffering from the same numbness that Bree is, but both are prefer their single state.  Somewhat counter to expectations, Jan seems perfectly happy alone, while Bree seems alienated and lonely.  Further, both conclusions are implied rather than explicitly shown.  With Pillow Talk, the conclusion is unmistakable for the time since we hear Brad (Hudson) is "pregnant";  with Klute we're left to decide for ourselves if Bree can control her self-destructive nature and Klute can be flexible enough to accommodate her.     The key is that both films present the growing strains of changing gender roles/rules for both men and women.  It's also significant that it begins much earlier than many might assume--not in the seventies, but by at least the late fifties, if not earlier (women had been working in significant numbers ever since WWII).
   As I mentioned, some categorize this as a film noir (if we assume noir can be considered a genre outside of a particular historical period).  I think it's more accurate to consider a noir woman's film (an oxymoron perhaps but it's not without precedence, as Mildred Pierce demonstrates)--or at least that's what it became when Bree Daniels became the focus of the film.  

7 comments:

  1. But was Day's character really wanting the independence of being single? She sure did jump at the chance to go out with Tex.

    It also seems strange calling Bree in a "single state" since she is with some many different men. I understand emotionally she is lonely, but she does have many relationships with men, just not that healthy of relationships!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I doubt Bree considers her arrangements with her clients as having a relationship with them (though Mr. Goldfarb may be an exception) any more than plumbers consider that they are having relationships with their customers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with Prof Kaufman, I consider all of Bree's encounters with clients as just doing business. What she really sought was a romantic relationship that she could control, maybe? She just possesses a knack for self-sabotage.

      And on Doris Day's character, didn't the maid talk her into going out with Tex? Jan seemed kind of reluctant to do it at first.

      Delete
    2. For me, it seems like these two characters in Klute and Pillow Talk actively spoke out against emotional involvements but wanted to be coaxed into them. Maybe like how a person says, "I never want to fall in love!" in the hopes that this will make the impact they wanted upon another person. I could be DEAD wrong, and probably am. Just a thought.

      Delete
  4. I can't seem to get this right... how bout this:

    I agree with Prof Kaufman, I consider all of Bree's encounters with clients as just doing business. What she really sought was a romantic relationship that she could control, maybe? She just possesses a knack for self-sabotage.

    And on Doris Day's character, didn't the maid talk her into going out with Tex? Jan seemed kind of reluctant to do it at first.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The idea of a Bree's "business" is a little unsettleing because of the nature of the business. In comparison to Pillow Talk, I think that Pillow Talk was not as harsh and easier to watch.

    ReplyDelete